The Scotsman - Monday, 6th May 1889, page 5

Renton v Celtic - The first of the Glasgow Charity ties was decided at. Hampden Park on Saturday, and so great was the interest evinced in the meeting that over 18,000 spectators were present. M'Callum was absent from the front rank of the Celtic, and this caused a rearrangement of the entire forward line, Maley playing extreme right and Dowdes of the second string— a halfback—partnering Coleman on the left. M'Laughlin, formerly of the Hibs was introduced at back. Play commenced with Renton, who had their full strength, coming away brilliantly and scoring in the first minute of the game. This unexpected reverse completely demoralised their opponents, who though they played a pretty open game, did not display the same dash and combination. Renton were in great form and ere half-time J. Campbell and Harvey added two more goals to Renton's total. Through a misunderstanding between M'Call and Lindsay, the Celtic were enabled to gain their first point, The game throughout was on the rough side and free kicks were numerous. At half-time the score stood—Renton, three; Celtic, two: but on resuming the latter came away boldly, but were forced back. They failed at close quarters. M'Call and Harvey each shot splendid goals, and the final result of a hard game was-Renton, five; Celtic two. The cup is at present held by the Renton, who have had its custody for the past three years. Saturday's gate amounted to some £450.

Attendance 20,000

Celtic Team:-
Kelly John
McClaughlin
McKeown
Gallacher
Kelly Jas
McLaren
Maley T
Dunbar
Groves
Coleman
Dowds

Scorers:-
Groves
Untraced